“A Picture You Really Need To See”

ft_jackson.jpg

Or so the caption at the DailyKos post goes, purporting to find a parallel between the U.S. Army recruits at Fort Jackson, South Carolina, and the picture below…

hamas.jpg

I make a couple observations about these two photos:

1. The recruits in Ft. Jackson are not about to strap on a bomb, walk into a market, and indiscriminately kill hundreds, as the suicide bomber will. The suicide bomber will leave the weapon she’s so brazenly holding behind in favor of a hidden suicide vest.

2. The recruits in Ft. Jackson are holding up weapons that have been assigned to them by roster-number (I would know, I’ve been to basic training). Even if they wanted to take a picture of themselves holding only their Bibles, it would be nigh impossible, for they are required to have their arms secured on their person at all times (the Army has found that even well-disciplined men have left their arms behind in battle – this is part of an effort to overcome that problem).

3. The recruits in Ft. Jackson will be taught (per the Counter Insurgency Field Manual – authored by General David Petraeus) that civilian casualties are not “collateral damage” – but serious impediments to our success in Iraq and Afghanistan. The entire premise of counter-insurgency (COIN) is that a shift from force-protection (our own) to civilian protection (their own) is necessary in order to gain the civilian trust, even if it means greater loss of life to our own soldiers in the short run.

Finally, I would note that this comes from the same far-left fringe of the blogosphere that also thought maligning General Petraeus was the cool thing to do – taking out a full page ad in the New York Times, deriding him as “General Betrayus“.

The left has long had trouble hiding their anti-military persuasion, try as they might. But to see a military recruit holding a Bible (after all, the left has an equally palpable anti-Judeo-Christian sentiment) must have been too much for this blogger to resist.

God forbid (pardon the pun) our brave men and women in uniform seek the assurance of a Higher Power (as our greatest military leaders always have) as they do battle against those who hijack airplanes, wear suicide vests, employ improvised explosive devices (IED’s), target innocents, and otherwise lie, cheat and steal their way to a world-wide Islamist theocracy.

Don’t believe me? Then ask Benazir Bhutto, who just lost her life today in the fight against global jihad.

7 Comments

  1. GMH,

    I found this post to be very thoughtful and an excellent analysis of the current state of affairs around the world. It’s easy to see a similar image and assume that the U.S. soldiers are basically the same as those of Hamas. Your thoughts very clearly destroy that assumption and give our troops the respect they deserve. Thanks.

  2. Very good points. You make great distinctions and carefully analyze both photos.

  3. These extreme leftist always show their bravado from behind the keyboard. How many of them were there in Pakistan in Bhutto’s crowd? Where are they in marching in the streets of Saudi Arabia or Iran for Women’s rights? Indeed, how many of them have been ‘out in the world’, other than to ‘civilized’ (socialist) Europe?

    Bhutto’s fate was predictable; she was well aware she faced martydom for democracy. That is political courage, something you never really see in extreme leftists who write post like contained that disgusting comparison.

  4. [...] posted about a press release by the Military Religious Freedom Foundation (MRFF) and a subsequent post, by a DailyKos blogger who goes by “Troutfishing,” which compares U.S. troops to [...]

  5. Funny , i find it funny u learned people pick up such pics and compare things.Respected learned sir. plz dont judge Islam or Quran by what u get in Media or shown in media, why dont u just the book called Quran and then say does it really teach all what the world is talking abt(jihad, killing etc) Ironically there is no word Jihad in Quran. plz plz if u wanna see a muslim see Prophet Mohammeds ( peace be upon him) life.but dont highlight muslims who in name of islam do things which are unislamic.There are black sheeps in every community.Once again lastly JUDGE ISLAM BY HOLY QURAN AND BY AUTHENTIC SAYINGS OF PROPHET MOHAMMMED(PBUH).

  6. Mohammed Sajid, our problem is with Liberals who find it appropriate to compare radical islamists to our brave troops. You seem like a pretty reasonable guy. Don’t you have a problem with that too?

  7. [...] problem is very common with your kind. You are both unaware and ungrateful of the sacrifice we military families make on [...]


Comments RSS TrackBack Identifier URI

Leave a comment